More unevenness here. Note that the Karthäuserhof is 2022.
KARTHÄUSERHOF
2022 (Eitelsbach) Karthäuserhofberg Riesling GG
Stony nose with underlying white peach. Medium-weight, decent grip, good penetration. 93/A
Reichsgraf von KESSELSTATT
2023 (Kasel) Nies’chen Riesling GG
Spicy, floral nose and mouth, adequate acidity. 92(+)/A
MAXIMIN GRÜNHAUS/von SCHUBERT
2023 (Mertesdorf) Bruderberg Riesling GG
Good minerality and nice precision for the vintage but without the tightness and acidity of a a still better wine. 88/B-
2023 (Mertesdorf) Herrenberg Riesling GG
Slightly herbal nose typical of Herrenberg. Light in weight, some mineral/stony flavors. Moderate acidity. 90/B+
2023 (Mertesdorf) Abtsberg Riesling GG
Tighter, more precise than two other von Schubert wines. Still quite closed, but there is promise here. 92(+)/A